I had fully intended to post some ribald bit of fluff today as an antidote to yesterday’s stultifying tl:dr pudding episode. But some odious creature over at my other blog took me to task for not first posting the bread recipe I apparently promised I would. God, I hate people with functioning memories.

Fine. Here’s your stupid bread post.

Ok first, let’s get one thing straight. The recipe I’m posting here is not for some artisan loaf that “Chez Boulanger” would be proud to serve for $17 a slice. It’s for a no-frills everyday white sandwich loaf, commonly known as “American bread”, ~ $.03/slice.

If you ARE looking to make the kind of bread that would make even a Frenchman like you, you want to head over to Bewitching Kitchen. SallyBR (aka “The Iron Uptake Chef”) is an actual, bona fide, no kidding, “just like Dexter’s Lab!” working research scientist. And she applies her anal-retentive mania for exactness – necessary in her profession – to her cooking passion as well. Her breadsΒ  particularly. She’s one of those obsessed nuts ardent perfectionists who owns a proofing box, measures percent hydration, uses a CRISPR-Cas9 to genetically engineer her own strains of bacteria for sourdough (I don’t even know what that means), and writes her own recipe code. All so she can have the best damn peanut butter and jelly sandwich on the planet. So yeah, if that’s your goal, head there.

(BTW, I’ve been making her ‘Bolo de Fuba’ on a regular basis since she first printed the recipe seven years ago. That’s a record for me. It is – she is – that good.)

Enough brown nosing. Here we go.

For this tutorial I did something I rarely ever do when making bread: I measured the ingredients. I normally just pour some flour and yeast into a bowl, then add in enough liquid and some kind of sugary stuff til it feels like dough (sorry, Sally). But that doesn’t translate very well to internet instruction, so I went back and looked for the notes I made when I first started making this recipe around 20 years ago.

I also timed everything out. When I last harangued people to start making their own bread I noted it could be done in two hours start to finish. That was a guess. This time it’s not. I did this in just under a deuce. You can too.

See for yourself:

Basic American White Bread

Mise en place:

1 c. Milk (yes, that’s a bottle of buttermilk in the picture. I was out of milk so I used what I had: 2/3 buttermilk, 1/3 half and half. You can just use milk.)

3 1/2 c. flour (any kind will do, other than perhaps cake flour. Don’t sweat it.)

salt (er, forgot to measure this…maybe two teaspoons? Something like that.)

3 Tablespoons honey

2 Tablespoons butter

1/3 cup water

and RAPID RISE yeast. That’s crucial here if you wanna meet the time schedule. Rapid rise, not “active”. Also, make sure it’s a pretty recent pack you got there. Dead yeast means no bread.

Bread 1



Stir the flour, salt, and yeast together in the bowl of a stand mixer.

In a microwaveable measuring cup place the milk, water, honey, and butter and nuke it on high for around a minute. Long enough to get it between 110 and 120 degrees. Stir it til the butter melts completely. (No microwave? Do it on the stove. Do I really have to tell you that?)

Bread 2


Slowly pour the liquid into the running mixer fixed with a dough hook (my KA is set on Speed 2). Little tip I discovered that helps a lot: lightly grease the dough hook before you start. That’ll help keep the dough from “climbing” to the top, an annoyance that used to almost keep me from using the thing:

Bread 3


Let it spin for 10 minutes. Don’t go longer than that if you can help it. Over-kneading is something that will ruin a loaf faster than almost anything else. Other than the other stuff that will ruin a loaf quickly also, I mean:

Bread 4


After your stand mixer has been stand mixing for 5 minutes do this: put a microwave safe bowl or measuring cup in the microwave and microwave on high for 5 minutes. Don’t open the door when it dings. Congrats – you just made a highly inaccurate, but effective, proofing box! Or at least, I think you did:

Bread 5


After 10 minutes dump the dough onto a floured surface (and set the mixing bowl to the side – you’re gonna use it again in just a minute). Using your impressively masculine hand, knead the ball a few times. Really, just 10 – 15 good down-and-away pushes with the heel of your hand is all you need.

Bread 6


After 10 – 15 massages of your doughy ball, form it into more of a ball. Doesn’t have to be exact, and don’t worry that it looks like a brain, or the bottom has a bunch of seams that didn’t stick together. It’s fine, bub:

Bread 7


Now take the dough brain and dump it back into the mixer bowl. The bowl you have lightly oiled/greased/sprayed even though I forgot to mention it. Then cover with plastic wrap:

Bread 8


NOW open the microwave door, and quickly put the bowl in (leave the container of hot water in with it). Close the door, and leave it closed for the next 45 minutes. This is your “first rise”.


Whatever you do, and I’m not kidding around here, do not stick anything – a fork, a whisk, your finger, your wife’s finger, a tribble – into the water you just microwaved. There is the possibility, however slight, that superheated (ie: heated above the boiling point) water could explode out once you introduce what’s called a “nucleation site”. If you want to learn more about it, here’s the Snopes page, with links to the FDA warnings, engineering sites talking about it, etc. Seriously, take this one seriously:

Bread 9


After 45 minutes, my ball got huge. That’s what you want. A huge ball.

If yours is not huge, it may be because of things like an unexpectedly colder temperature, half-dead yeast, or some other things that are still a mystery to me.Β  Whatever. If your ball isn’t big enough, re-heat the water for a minute or two and stick the ball back in. Check it every 15 minutes or so until it meets your size requirement. Which is “big”. Go listen to that AC/DC song for inspiration.

Here’s my big ball:

Bread 10


You ever heard the advice to “punch the dough down” after the first rise?


Dough balls, like all other balls, don’t like being punched. Just press the ball down gently. Balls like that much, much more. Seriously, don’t punch your ball. Aside from the double entendre thing, you could actually cause the dough to stiffen if you slam into it here.

Just remove the dough ball to a floured surface again, and start pressing down, spreading it out. You can tug it and pull it, too (yes, back to double entendres):

Bread 11


This is your goal. You want to push, tug, and pull the dough into a rough rectangle as wide as your loaf pan is long. My own trick is to put the loaf pan right there so I can tell easily. (A note here: I am using a long loaf pan, which as the name implies, is longer than your usual department store loaf pan. If all you have is one of the smaller jobs, your loaf will be shorter but higher. I prefer making longer loafs that aren’t quite as tall. But don’t worry, yours will be fine. Just taller. And stubbier. Stubby.):

Bread 12


By the way, before I forget again: lightly oil/spray the loaf pan all over the inside. Don’t forget the top rim and handles, because sometimes the dough rises over the rim and can stick to those surfaces.

Now start rolling the dough into a tight log. If the edges start ballooning out, just pat them back towards the center. Try to make it pretty damn tight, not just two or three rotations:

Bread 13


Make yours look like this. If it doesn’t, leave me a note and I’ll mail you out one of mine. (BTW, if it’s not obvious: this is seam-side down, the end pieces folded over so it doesn’t look like an open jelly roll):

Bread 14


Put the log in the loaf pan. If you used the pan as a guide while you rolled, it should fit in perfectly:

Bread 15


Now comes the second (and last) rise. No microwave this time. See what I did here? I’ve got two pots of water set on a low simmer, with the loaf pan on a trivet between them. The oven is on, pre-heating to 350(f). This gives a good temp for the second rise, which take around 20 minutes. Cover the loaf pan with plastic wrap. (BTW, do use a trivet here. The stovetop can get warm enough from the oven pre-heating to start cooking the bottom of the loaf.):

Bread 16


This was what I saw when my timer went off after exactly 20 minutes. It’s what you want to see as well:

Bread 17


You’re now ready for the final lap. Soon, all those carbs will be yours!

Now take a good, sharp, thin bladed knife (or a bread “lame” if you have one, but unless you’re Sally I know you don’t) and hold it menacingly against the throat of the dough until it gives up the dough:

Bread 18


The stupid dough refused to hand over the dough!

You know what that means:

Bread 19

So sad. Send a bouquet of flours to the widow.


Ok, now comes the cookin’. Place the loaf onto the bottom rack of your 350-degree oven, towards the back. In front, place one of those pots of simmering water you had on the stove. That will give off some moisture as the loaf cooks, and through some kind of science-y magic I don’t understand, help the crust. Or something. I dunno. Just do it:

Bread 20


Set your timer for 15 minutes. After 15 minutes rotate the bread pan around, so the front side now faces the back. Set your timer for 15 minutes again.

When you timer goes off, check the temperature. You want the internal temp to be around 190-ish. A bit more won’t hurt, but don’t go under or you risk having spots of raw dough in your loaf.

Like rising times, baking times can also vary a bit. Normally 30 minutes does it for me with this recipe, but this time it took 38 minutes to hit the target:

Bread 21


Now just turn it out onto a rack – anything that will keep the bottom elevated so it’s not sitting on a flat surface and steaming will do – and then…wait.

You gotta wait because…wait for it…more science! As the temperature slowly comes down some chemical reactions take place inside the loaf forming various flavor compounds. If you cut into the loaf too quickly, the internal temperature will drop fast enough that it will keep those reactions from happening. It’s true, I read it in a book! Anyway, just hold your horses for a few minutes, bucko. That loaf ain’t goin’ nowhere:

Bread 22

You see my loaf came out very cleanly. If yours is sticking, don’t force it out by pulling the top, spraying it with WD-40, or doing anything else stupid. Just run a thin bladed knife, like a boning knife, gently along each side between the bread and the pan. I will say that with the modern non-stick pans that you can get anywhere this is hardly ever a problem, and the dark coloring makes an excellent loaf on top of that. But I like using my cobalt blue stoneware Le Creuset because…shut up. I just like it, ok? I mean c’mon – cobalt blue!


Finally enough time has passed. The loaf is still warm, but not TOO warm. So….


Yup. Dive in.

Butter and salt is the only music your bread needs to sing:

Bread 23

I want to call your attention to that nice even crumb for a second. That’s from rolling the dough log very tightly back there. If you do it loosely, well, you’ll just end up in tears. In tears and eating bread with a loose crumb. So again: tight.

Now let’s see if my time prediction in that previous post held up, or do I suck:

1 minute 15 seconds heating the liquid ingredients.

10 minutes machine kneading.

30 seconds hand kneading.

45 minutes first rise.

2 minutes rolling into a (tight!) log.

20 minutes second rise.

38 minutes baking.


116 minutes, 45 seconds.

1 hour, 56 minutes, 45 seconds.

That’s…that’s less than two hours, right?

It is! Yes!


Take THAT, SallyBR! You think you’re so smart just because you’re so smart. HA!

Finally, just to wrap things up (before I go have more carbs…mmmm….), those of you who’ve been reading me for a while know I’ve had this ongoing “bread experiment”. See, I have this theory that any liquid which doesn’t kill yeast can be turned into bread by adding flour and yeast to it. If you go back through my archives you’ll see loaves I’ve turned out using melted ice cream, various soups, Earl Grey tea, Korean ginger-cinnamon drink, sauerkraut, etc. So far, I have not had one failure. And this is the base recipe I use. So if you want to try your own bread experiment, follow along with what I did here, but substitute your own insane liquid choice for the water/milk combo. And let me know how brilliant I am in the comments (or how much I suck, depending).

There ya go, fellow blogger who shrilly requested this. I hope you’re happy. Or at least, shut up for a while.

NOW the next time I come back, it’ll be with stories and jocularity. Unless somebody harangues me for something else again. Please don’t. Just loaf contentedly until I get back.





32 thoughts on “Loafing

  1. OMG! You are going to give me a heart attack! Cannot believe I’ve been featured in your site, with such high levels of praise… c’mon… obsessed nuts? I am touched. Truer words were never spoken. Written, rather. But you can definitely broadcast that in your radio show, if you insist on making them spoken words too…

    thank you!!!!!

    I haven’t stuck my finger in over-heated water, but sliced the tip of my finger cutting a cake today. And yes, I grabbed some pie weights that rolled out of said pie crust after being in the oven at 390C for 20 min. I am just clever like that. But I can do CRISPR-Cas with my eyes closed…

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Lol. A mention of your brilliant cooking mecca was loooong overdue here, considering how much I visit it AND use its recipes. I would turn to your baking tips before going to check with Rose Levy Beranbaum. I’m not kidding. I’ve loved your stuff for literally YEARS, and not just because you only weigh 75 pounds and probably wax. So yes, I feel like apologizing that this is the first time I’ve graced you thus πŸ™‚

      (And believe it or not, I have actually mentioned you on the radio – on WOR in NYC, back when Tyler Florence was our mid-day guy. You’re famous, chica!)

      OUCHY! Lol…hope your mangled finger doesn’t cause you to accidentally insert a wrong strand of rRNA somewhere! You might end up with yeast that makes bread taste….healthy! NOOOOO!!!


      Liked by 1 person

      1. ok, another heart attack… I’ve been on air! On air! On the radio waves! let me surf that for a while… feels good!

        And no, I weigh 98 pounds. Give or take a pound or two. πŸ˜‰

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Lol. Don’t let it go to your head πŸ™‚

          NINETY EIGHT POUNDS?! What happened? Did you have to go on a heavy course of steroids for some hideous condition? Are you retaining water….for 5 months? Wearing ankle weights? What happened? HOW DID YOU GET SO FAT??!

          Liked by 1 person

            1. Don’t try poutine, you’ll never recover! Look what happened to Canada!!

              All those other things…ok, I couldn’t resist them either. You’re forgiven. As long as you go on the Worm Diet so you can get back to your normal goddess weight….


              Liked by 1 person

    1. Lol. You can do it! (And if you need an EVEN SIMPLER recipe, just ask. Believe or not, I know some.)

      I like the pretty blue mixer too, but the fact that it matches that loaf pan is mere coincidence. Every year on my birthday NewWifey(tm) gets me a new piece of Le Creuset in a different color (I posted a pic of the collection here last year, if I recall). It’s just by chance this pan and my mixer match. My other Le Creuset bread loaf pan (smaller) is cherry red. Like my eyes this morning πŸ™‚


    1. You better not be lying to me again. I can take lies about our relationship, your appreciation of my Milli Vanilli 8-track collection, even my superfluous 5th nipple. But if you build my hopes up about loafing, and then dash those hopes….oh, who am I kidding. I can’t quit you, man!

      But I do hope you make it. And listen, if you can’t find the instant stuff, regular ol’ “active” yeast will work too. Just realize it will take a bit longer, and active yeast needs to be proofed first and added to the liquid ingredients. Instant yeast is dumped into the dry stuff, no proofing.

      Lemme know if you do give it a shot. Whatever year that happens to be. Good luck!


      Liked by 1 person

  2. Excellent advice on the water in the microwave! I was making hummingbird food and boiled the water in the microwave. I poured the sugar into the measuring cup and the water explode up to the ceiling! Luckily I didn’t get burnt.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Whew! I’m glad you were ok. Yeah, that’s an important bit of advice I got years ago. I think more people should be aware of it, particularly as microwaves are so prevalent. Thanks so much for stopping by, and for commenting! πŸ™‚

      Liked by 1 person

    1. My god, somebody actually tried something I posted?! I think that’s a first! I’m so proud….and happy that it came out ok for you. Bravo!! Thanks for letting me know πŸ™‚

      And thanks for the email. I did get it, and responded. You rock.


  3. Mmm, makes me want nice warm bread and butter now! Thanks for including the don’t-be-a-dope warning about blowing up water that came out of microwaves. Can’t trust common sense anymore, sad to say.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. You have thermometer?!! Curse you.

    I have had that Thermopop thermometer on my TO BUY for ME list for ages. But have yet to justify buying one. Cause I want the red one and the blue one and the white one. (No, I’m Canadian. But thanks for asking.) And purple. Purple is my favourite colour. I was born in February and the amethyst if my birthstone … so sue me, I’m a girl.

    Sorry, I got carried away there.

    To get back to what I was going to say … I like baking bread and enjoyed seeing your basic sandwich bread recipe. I used to use the microwave with a measuring cup full of boiling hot water trick too until the ‘oven with the light on’ option was revealed to me and became my new proofing method. Cause my microwave oven is small and my half sheet baking sheet doesn’t fit in there. πŸ™‚

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes! I have your thermometer! AND YOU CAN’T HAVE IT! Bwahahahaaaaaaaaa!! (I didn’t get the $100/US ThermoPen big boy because…$100/US? Are you kidding?? This cute little lollipop pup was only 25, and just as accurate. And I fully understand the insistence on color πŸ™‚ )

      Yeah, the “use the oven light” seems to be ubiquitous advice. But as mine hardly ever works….


      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s